The real cost of a resignation is not in the job ad. It's in everything that person knew and never wrote down anywhere.
This article is part of the Small Business Series: 13 short, practical articles for small and mid-sized businesses that want to compete with the big players without being their size. They all revolve around one idea: what your people know how to do is your biggest advantage, as long as it doesn't live only in someone's head. We'll look at how to put it in writing, teach it fast, prove it to your customers and measure it. A new article every Monday.
Carlos left on Friday. On Monday, nobody knows how to close out the register.
Carlos worked with you for four years. He knew which supplier to call when something ran out. He knew how to get the machine going when it jammed. He could figure out Monday's order without looking at any paper.
Nobody asked him to write it down. There was no need. Carlos was there.
Then one day Carlos found another job. He handed in his notice, said a kind goodbye, and left. And something left with him that wasn't in any contract: the way things got done.
This happens to a lot of small businesses. Not because anyone did something wrong. It happens because when something works, nobody thinks to write it down.
What you see and what you don't
When someone quits, most people think about the costs they can see:
- Posting the job.
- Reading resumes and doing interviews.
- The paperwork for the person leaving and the person starting.
Those costs are real, but they're the small part. The big part is hidden, because it never shows up as a bill:
1. The new hire's learning curve
The new person earns a full salary from day one. But for weeks, they only get done part of what Carlos did. You pay for that gap.
2. Mistakes in the first few weeks
Wrong orders. Product that goes to waste. A customer who gets poor service and doesn't come back. Work that has to be done twice. Nobody does it on purpose. They just don't know yet.
3. The owner's or supervisor's time
Someone has to teach the same things they already taught last year. Those hours come out of their own work. Often, that someone is you.
4. What is lost for good
The tricks, the contacts, the exceptions. The things Carlos knew that nobody knew Carlos knew. You find out the day something breaks.
Put a number on it, even a rough one
The hidden becomes visible when you add it up. Here's a simple example. The numbers are made up, just to show the method. Yours will be different.
| Item | How to calculate it | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Learning curve | Monthly salary × months until fully productive × share of work not getting done | $800 × 2 months × 50% = $800 |
| Mistakes in the first few weeks | Your best guess of waste, rework and lost customers | $300 |
| Supervisor's time | Hours per week teaching × weeks × cost per hour | 5 h × 8 weeks × $10 = $400 |
| Total per person who leaves | $1,500 | |
| Total per year | Total per person who leaves × people who leave per year | $1,500 × 10 people = $15,000 |
Notice something: none of this shows up in your reports as a "turnover cost." It's spread around. A bit in payroll, a bit in waste, a bit in overtime, a bit in customers who didn't come back. That's why almost nobody sees it.
Think of the last person who left a key role. Ask their supervisor: how many weeks did it take the replacement to work alone? What mistakes happened during that time? With those two answers, you already have half your number.
The idea: knowledge that lives only in someone's head isn't yours
If what your business knows how to do lives only in someone's head, it doesn't belong to your business. You're just borrowing it.
This has nothing to do with not trusting your people. Good people quit. They get sick, go on vacation, get promoted. And even if they stay forever, they can only be in one place at a time.
When knowledge lives outside a head, written down, recorded, turned into something another person can learn, something good happens. It stops being a risk and becomes an asset. Something you can teach, improve and multiply.
Does your business depend on one person's head?
- Some tasks only one person knows how to do.
- When that person goes on vacation, something runs late or goes wrong.
- New people learn by "watching" someone, with nothing written down.
- If you ask "where is this written down?", the answer is "ask...".
- Each supervisor teaches their own version of the same job.
If you checked two or more, an important part of your operation is borrowed.
Three things you can do this week
- Make the list. Write down the five tasks that only one person knows how to do today.
- Ask them to explain it out loud. Sit with that person for fifteen minutes while they do the task. Record it or take notes. It doesn't have to look nice.
- Save it where the next person will find it. Somewhere a new hire can get to without having to ask anyone.
It doesn't have to be perfect. It just has to be out of one person's head. In the next articles in this series, we'll see how to turn that into something that teaches on its own.
Frequently asked questions
What if the person doesn't want to share what they know?
It happens, and it's almost always fear of becoming replaceable. Make it part of their role and give them the credit: "you're the one who knows this, help us keep it from getting lost." People who teach well are often the ones who grow the most.
Isn't writing things down just more red tape?
Only if you write long documents nobody uses. The idea is the opposite: a few short things, easy to find, and only about what really matters.
If everything lives in people's heads, where do I start?
With the role that turns over the most, or the task that costs you the most when it goes wrong. Just one task, well documented, already saves you next time.
How much does it cost you? Put a number on it.
On October 20, we'll work out the hidden cost of turnover live. Everyone who attends gets the calculator to use with their own numbers.
All 13 articles in the series
- September 28When the person who knew leaves, what they knew leaves too ← you are here
- October 5Your onboarding lives in one person's head (and that person gets tired)
- October 1215 people start on Monday. Today is Thursday.
- October 19Your best employee stopped performing. Don't fire them yet.
- October 26You know what turnover costs you. Here's what to do with that number.
- November 2The 40-page manual nobody read
- November 9The question that knocks you out of the bid
- November 16Your distributor sells your product badly. The distributor isn't the problem.
- November 23Your know-how lives in three people. That's why you can't open the fourth location
- November 30What you need to be able to prove if there's an accident tomorrow
- December 7The appendix that wins proposals
- December 14Much of your turnover happens in the first 90 days
- December 212027 budget: how to justify training when no department asks for it
Ready to transform your corporate training?
See real results from companies that train with SHIFT — or talk to our team.